• Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
Follow Thatcham Research

Disappointing year-end sees six three-star Euro NCAP ratings, and the first ever zero-star rating

Press release   •   Dec 13, 2017 09:00 GMT

The FIAT Punto in Euro NCAP's side crash test
  • Relaunched FIAT Punto scores unprecedented zero-star Euro NCAP rating
  • The Alfa Romeo Giulietta, Dacia Duster, Ford C-MAX / Grand C-MAX, Vauxhall Karl, Citroen DS 3 and MG ZS only achieve three-star Euro NCAP ratings
  • Five-star ratings for the Hyundai KONA, Jaguar Land Rover F-Pace, Kia Stinger, BMW 6 Series GT and Toyota Yaris

The final Euro NCAP test results of 2017 have shown that some carmakers are still choosing not to fit potentially life-saving technologies to new models.

All 16 cars announced this November achieved five-star Euro NCAP ratings, but December’s release has seen six three-star Euro NCAP ratings and the first zero-star rating since testing began 20 years ago.

A tale of two Citroens

Although the zero-star Euro NCAP rating for the FIAT Punto is eye-catching, it’s the three-star ratings for carmakers that have delivered five-star cars in the recent past which are most surprising, comments Matthew Avery, director of research, Thatcham Research:

“This is a tale of two Citroens. In November, the DS 7 Crossback achieved a five-star Euro NCAP rating – and came with standard-fit AEB and Lane Departure Warnings. The DS is a premium brand, but Citroen has made a clear decision with the DS 3, offering AEB as an option only.

“Some great strides have been made in car safety this year. 72 per cent of the cars tested achieved a five-star Euro NCAP rating, versus 56 per cent in 2016. But December’s test results have shown that some carmakers are choosing not to fit potentially life-saving safety technology as standard, despite an overall trend to the contrary in 2017.

“It’s about decision making – some are choosing to prioritise the fitment of technologies to support drivers and bring down accident rates. Others are not.

“This is now imperative. From the beginning of 2018 vehicles without standard-fit AEB systems won’t be able to achieve a five-star Euro NCAP rating.”

The three-star Euro NCAP rated Alfa Romeo Giulietta, Dacia Duster, Vauxhall Karl and MG ZS could only muster a combined average driver assistance and crash avoidance score of 29 per cent. None feature any standard-fit AEB systems. In contrast, the 2017 Alfa Romeo Stelvio achieved a five-star Euro NCAP rating, while the Vauxhall Insignia features in Thatcham Research’s top ten safest cars of the year.

The Ford C-Max vehicles tested by Euro NCAP also offered little in the way of safety technology, and performed below expectation in impact testing. Avery comments, “As a major player in the market, targeting vehicles at the family market, the results for Ford’s C-Max cars disappoint. There is a distinct lack of safety technology to help avoid collisions, and below average adult and child occupant scores in the event of a collision.”

Nul Points

The zero-star Euro NCAP rating for the FIAT Punto, a re-release of the 2005 version, came because of low scores for its crash performance, combined with the absence of key technologies such as Autonomous Emergency Braking (AEB) and Lane Support Systems - giving it an unprecedented 0% ‘Safety Assist’ result.

“In 2005 the FIAT Punto achieved a good rating. However, Euro NCAP frequently raises the bar in its testing regime – and the FIAT Punto’s adult occupant protection score of 51% is more than 30% below the average for the Superminis tested in 2017,” comments Avery. “Yes this is essentially an old car, but that should have sharpened the focus on fitting safety technologies to counteract it’s dated crash performance.”

The Jaguar Land Rover F-Pace, Kia Stinger, Toyota Yaris, fourth generation BMW 6 Series and Hyundai KONA all achieved five-star Euro NCAP ratings. 

Thatcham Research is the independent voice of automotive safety & repair, advising motorists, insurers and vehicle manufacturers to help reduce accident frequency, severity and costs and to realise the vision of ‘Safer cars, fewer crashes’.

As well as its world leading crash and track research, Thatcham Research tests and accredits crash repair parts, vehicle repair technicians, and a number of other products and services within the collision repair industry for insurers, motor manufacturers, equipment manufacturers and suppliers.

In addition, Thatcham Research has been at the forefront of vehicle security since the 1990s when it introduced the New Vehicle Security Assessment (NVSA) to address levels of vehicle crime.

A founder member of the international Research Council for Automobile Repairs (RCAR), Thatcham Research has also been a member of the European New Car Assessment Programme (Euro NCAP) since 2004.